| Wis Heights | Nolan Keith | 10 | First Team | DH |
| Cambridge | Kiefer Parish | 12 | First Team | Catcher |
| Cambridge | Jett Horton | 11 | First Team | Infield |
| New Glarus | Nolan Julseth | 10 | First Team | Infield |
| New Glarus | Landon Stelter | 11 | First Team | Infield |
| Wis Heights | River Lubchanski | 10 | First Team | Infield |
| Cambridge | Matt Buckman | 12 | First Team | Outfield |
| New Glarus | Ethan Colstad | 9 | First Team | Outfield |
| Wis Heights | Quinn Payne | 11 | First Team | Outfield |
| Belleville | Niles Monroe | 12 | First Team | Pitcher |
| Cambridge | Clayton Stenjem | 12 | First Team | Pitcher |
| New Glarus | Patrick Alt | 12 | First Team | Pitcher |
| Marshall | Carson Connelly | 12 | First Team | Utility |
| Wis Heights | Reed Adler | 12 | First Team | Utility |
| New Glarus | Ashlin Mihlbauer | 11 | Second Team | Catcher |
| Belleville | James Markhardt | 12 | Second Team | Infield |
| Marshall | Brady Kleinheinz | 11 | Second Team | Infield |
| Marshall | Mason Aldworth | 10 | Second Team | Infield |
| Wis Heights | Fin Hinderman | 12 | Second Team | Infield |
| New Glarus | Kamm Nehmer | 9 | Second Team | Outfield |
| Waterloo | Shea Sellnow | 10 | Second Team | Outfield |
| Wis Heights | Ryan Flynn | 11 | Second Team | Outfield |
| Cambridge | Cal Nottestad | 11 | Second Team | Pitcher |
| Marshall | Logan Ney | 10 | Second Team | Pitcher |
| Cambridge | Evan Harbort | 9 | Second Team | Utility |
| Marshall | Teseo Ruelas | 12 | Honorable Mention | Catcher |
| Wis Heights | Charlie Reader | 10 | Honorable Mention | Catcher |
| New Glarus | Braden Rear | 11 | Honorable Mention | Infield |
| New Glarus | Nate Hendrickson | 12 | Honorable Mention | Infield |
| Wis Heights | Zac Sander | 11 | Honorable Mention | Infield |
| Belleville | Marcus Hebgen | 10 | Honorable Mention | Pitcher |
| Belleville | Austin Mckinley | 10 | Honorable Mention | Pitcher |
| Waterloo | Bryce Aubart | 12 | Honorable Mention | Pitcher |
| Waterloo | Ryder Jaehnke | 11 | Honorable Mention | Pitcher |
2025 All-Capitol South Baseball Team
